While reflecting last week on my wine experiences from 2006, I got to thinking what makes a wine memorable and what type of wine would I drink if I had to have the same wine for the rest of my life?
I emailed some friends and colleagues and asked them the age old question (I'm sure you've heard this question in one form or another):
If you were stranded on a desert island and could only choose one type of wine to drink for the rest of your life what would it be and why?
I invited them to use their imagination and try to consider such factors as the island's food supply. Here are some of my favorite responses.
James, witty sommelier: "The old Desert Island question...I want to lean towards St. Joseph or any wine from the Northern Rhone and Duck confit and maybe some foie gras butter with fresh baked brioche, just because if we’re never getting off this island, might as well live in sin. The other half has to go with the obvious - German Riesling. Probably Spatlese from the Mosel or anything from Helmut Hexhamer or Helmut Dönnhoff. What is with guys named Helmut from the Nahe region? As far as the food for the Riesling - tomato and jalapeno seeds. I’ll plant them, fish all day and have ceviche for the rest of my days...how does Riesling taste out of a coconut anyway?"
Greg, my favorite Walla Walla Winemaker: "Gramercy Cellars Walla Walla Syrah 2005 - because if I was stuck on an island, there wouldn’t be anyone to sell it!"
Peter, all around "good guy" and exceptional wine professional: "Tough... a few thoughts - 1996 Bollinger Grand Anee Rose Champagne. It could be the non-Rose too but has to be '96 although the '95 is singing these days as well. For me, it is the greatest champagne of my generation. Others in my office have said '82 Salon but I am a huge fan of the Bollinger style and the '96 vintage in particular. It's just the right balance for my palate of fruit, acid and yeast. It can be drunk young but has the stuffing to last forever just in case rescue is far off."
Melissa, entertaining wine educator: "Such a tough question...it's so hard to pick just one, but I think If I were given the choice I would drink Champagne. I have never quite figured out or have been able to express in words why I love Champagne so much. I feel more strongly about it than almost any other wine and drink it as often or more than any other. My attachment frighteningly borders on an emotional level as well. When it's good...really good...I get a little vachlemt (insert Saturday Night Live's Linda Richman voice here). Plus with the salty food and air - what could be better?"
Rory, another witty Chicago Sommelier: "German Riesling (Kabinet-Spatelse), because it is lower alcohol and refreshing and my Island is very hot I and I am very thirsty."
Cindy, vice president of operations for a very cool culinary school: "Hands down it would be Krug MV. Taking into account that I would be drinking a lot of it and it would be hot. An unlimited supply of lobster and caviar would be necessary. What about you?"
Well, that is a good question Cindy. I have so many favorites. Maybe it would be Trimbach "Clos St Hune" Riesling from Alsace because it is unique and is a monopoly (privately owned vineyard) and Riesling’s is so versatile with food. Although it could also be Raveneau Chablis "Les Clos" from Burgundy because the Chardonnay is rich and the wine bottle is heavy enough where it could be used as a weapon to fight off...wild animals.
Nah, my final answer would definitely be Groffier Chambolle-Musigny, 1er Cru 'Amoureuses' from Burgundy. It is silky, has ripe fruit, and yet is earthy with wild mushrooms and truffles. The premier cru name translates as "the lovers" and is so good.
Me. A desert island. And Cru 'Amoureuses.' Now if I could only bring that one perfect person to share it with...







Recent Comments